@techreport{LhARA-TN-2026-04,
type = {Report}, title = {A global picture of laser-driven radiobiology and the PoPLaR experiment}, url = {https://ccap.hep.ph.ic.ac.uk/trac/raw-attachment/wiki/Research/LhARA/Documents/LhARA-TN-2026-04.pdf}, abstract = {Laser-driven proton and ion sources deliver nanosecond-scale bunches at instantaneous dose rates of 107-109 Gy/s, but their broad spectra, large divergence and shot-to-shot variability mean that the field delivered to a biological sample is defined by the complete source-to-sample system. This technical note has two purposes: to establish the current global standing of laser-driven radiobiology and to use this to assess the Proof-of-Principle LhARA Radiobiology experiment (PoPLaR) at SCAPA against the current field. This will determine areas of prioritisation in the field and guide the next phase of the PoPLaR design. A systematic review study identified 22 publications (2009–2025) on laser-driven proton and ion radiobiology, including in vitro and in vivo experiments across both normal and tumour cell studies. Irradiation conditions were compiled and analysed to search for trends in the global body of published work. The data exhibited an overall increase in maximum particle energy by publication year (r=0.921, p=4.97x10−10), showing progression in the field over time.
The global dataset is dominated by both proton and in vitro studies, with only four in vivo experiments and only a single non-proton ion study (carbon). A minimum reporting standard for the field is recommended in order to directly compare studies as there appears to be inconsistent reporting of beam characteristics. Examining the global biological data, a difference is observed between tissue types in the laser-driven dataset: normal tissue cells appear to exhibit steeper survival curves than tumour cells under laser-driven proton irradiation. Conventional proton data, by contrast, show both normal and tumour cell survival curves exhibit comparable steepness to that of the laser-driven normal tissue curves. No other trends can be deciphered between survival and beamline parameters, or in the global γH2AX foci detection data, due to limited available data.
PoPLaR successfully transported protons from the SCAPA source (~6 J,~25 fs pulses on 12.7 $\mu$m Kapton; median fitted cutoff 11.8 MeV over 48 Thomson-parabola shots) through a 150 T m−1 PMQ doublet and Cu scatterer to a 2.7 cm2 cell-dish field. FaDu cells received 0.57$\pm$0.03 Gy per shot with a spatial coefficient of variation of 13.9\%, during the first biological phase of PoPLaR. The irradiation energy, dose and field size recorded during the PoPLaR experiments align with the other reported in vitro experiments in the field. The preliminary survival data is within the order of the global data but trends are not distiguishable at this stage. Limitations with PoPLaR is dominated by dose control: the dose fluctuation of 24–38\% per multi-shot exposure and the absence of an on-shot diagnostic. These properties should be prioritised for the next phase of PoPLaR experiments.}, urldate = {2026-11-xx}, institution = {Imperial}, author = {McGarrigle, J.M.}, year = {2026},
}
